April 10, 2023

Gautam Adani seems to have lost his fortune. After climbing his way to the top as the 3rd richest man in the world in August 2022, a series of reports by short-selling firm, The Hindenburg Group, wiped a significant chunk of his fortune off the board. At the center of Hindenburg’s allegations against Gautam Adani was a network of Mauritian shell companies, which the group alleges was controlled by his brother Vinod Adani.

In addition to questions from Hindenburg, questions regarding the nature of Adani’s affiliates were raised in the Indian parliament, with opposition leaders demanding more transparency from Adani and asking him to disclose more details about the companies in Mauritius. However, the systems in place that allowed such foreign companies to have an influence on India have been in place for the last 20 years.

Foreign Direct Investment or FDI as it’s more popularly known has been a common refrain in the Indian economy. In the early 90s, the immediate aftermath of the liberalization of the economy saw many excited at the prospect of India opening up its economy to foreign investors. At the time, India had a pre-existing tax agreement with the tiny island, which reduced the already low tax rate from fifteen to effectively three percent. This tax rate, coupled with the ease of setting up companies has meant that until 2018, Mauritius was the prime destination for visitors wanting to invest into India.

LG - 930px

Singapore and Mauritius acccount for over 50% of all investment

into India

Favourable Tax laws and easier administrative set ups have allowed Sinagapore and the Netherlands to

comeup as homes for companies looking to invest into India

Netherlands

UK

Japan

$20B

$7.4B

$16B

France

Germany

$5B

$4.5B

USA

$25B

UAE

Switzerland

$6B

$5.9B

Cayman

Islands

Singapore

$9B

$71B

Mauritius

$60B

Singapore and Mauritius

$130B

Rest of the World

$126B

Singapore and Mauritius acccount for over 50%

of all investment into India

Favourable Tax laws and easier administrative set ups have

allowed Sinagapore and the Netherlands to comeup as homes

for companies looking to invest into India

Netherlands

UK

Japan

$7.4B

$20B

$16B

France

Germany

$5B

$4.5B

USA

$25B

UAE

Switzerland

$6B

$5.9B

Cayman

Islands

Singapore

$71B

$9B

Mauritius

$60B

Singapore

and Mauritius

$130B

Rest of the

World

$126B

Singapore and Mauritius acccount for over 50% of all investment into

India

Favourable Tax laws and easier administrative set ups have allowed Sinagapore and the

Netherlands to comeup as homes for companies looking to invest into India

Netherlands

UK

Japan

$20B

$7.4B

$16B

France

Germany

$5B

$4.5B

USA

$25B

UAE

Switzerland

$6B

$5.9B

Cayman

Islands

Singapore

$9B

$71B

Mauritius

$60B

Singapore and Mauritius

$130B

Rest of the World

$126B

Singapore and Mauritius acccount for over 50% of all investment

into India

Favourable Tax laws and easier administrative set ups have allowed Sinagapore and the Netherlands to

comeup as homes for companies looking to invest into India

Netherlands

UK

Japan

$20B

$7.4B

$16B

France

Germany

$5B

$4.5B

USA

$25B

UAE

Switzerland

$6B

$5.9B

Cayman

Islands

Singapore

$9B

$71B

Mauritius

$60B

Singapore and Mauritius

Rest of the World

Over the years, India grew to become more liberalized, opening up it’s economy and allowing companies to invest into the country. Debates around what is called liberalization usually had two sides to the argument, with proponents arguing that opening up the economy would bring in some much needed stimulus for an ailing economy and opponents claiming that India’s indigenous companies or manufacturing base would not be able to compete.

Companies had 2 main ways to invest: Either by procuring shares with the permission of the Reserve Bank of India (the RBI) or by directly investing in shares if they were allowed to do so. Acquisitions and mergers that used to require months of extraneous government clearance now just takes hours. Foreign companies were also looking for ways to avoid paying taxes that ranged upto 30%, and were seeking to avoid bureaucratic hurdles that came with being a country requiring prior government clearance.

This started a phenomenon called treaty shopping. According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, treaty shopping takes place when a company or a person tries to take advantage of a tax treaty by not being a resident of that particular country. The OECD claims that this is done to avoid and evade the payment of tax. While none of the companies may claim to do so, it is widely assumed that this is the reason why these companies are growing in popularity.

Some of the biggest companies and startups have used funds that came from some of these countries. The telecom giant Jio, a subsidiary of the Indian conglomerate Reliance saw investments worth $15 billion trickle in from Meta and the Public Investment fund of Saudi Arabia. Other recipients include the financial technology company Paytm, which went public in 2021 and the education technology startup Byju’s.

Telecom companies are some of the biggest benefactors of foreign direct

investment

Bubbles show where different Indian companies get their money from

JIO Platforms

$15B

Vodafone IDEA

$10B

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

Mauritius

Singapore

United States of America

Singapore

United Arab Emirates

Amazon Services

Think and Learn

$4.8B

$2.9B

Canada

Singapore

Belgium

United States

of America

Cayman Islands

Singapore

Luxembourg

UK

Qatar

Netherlands

Mauritius

One97 Communications

OYO Rooms

$2.7B

$2.2B

Hong Kong

UK

Saudi Arabia

UK

Cayman Islands

Singapore

Cayman Islands

Virgin Islands

USA

Mauritius

United States

of America

Taiwan

Axis Bank

Airtel

$2.5B

$2.5B

Mauritius

USA

Mauritius

Singapore

Telecom companies are some of the

biggest benefactors of foreign direct

investment

Bubbles show which countries Indian companies get their

money from

JIO Platforms

$15B

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

USA

Singapore

UAE

Vodafone IDEA

$10B

Mauritius

Singapore

Amazon Services

$4.8B

Singapore

Luxembourg

Think and Learn

$2.9B

Singapore

Canada

Belgium

Cayman Islands

USA

UK

Qatar

Netherlands

Mauritius

One97 Communications

$2.7B

Hong Kong

UK

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

Singapore

Mauritius

USA

Taiwan

Axis Bank

Airtel

$2.5B

$2.5B

Singapore

Mauritius

Mauritius

USA

OYO Rooms

$2.2B

UK

Cayman Islands

Virgin Islands

USA

Telecom companies are some of the biggest benefactors of

foreign direct investment

Bubbles show which countries Indian companies get their money from

JIO Platforms

$15B

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

Singapore

USA

UAE

Vodafone IDEA

$10B

Mauritius

Singapore

Amazon Services

$4.8B

Singapore

Luxembourg

One97 Communications

Think and Learn

$2.9B

$2.7B

Singapore

Canada

Hong Kong

Belgium

UK

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

USA

Cayman Islands

Singapore

UK

Qatar

Mauritius

Netherlands

Taiwan

USA

Mauritius

Airtel

Axis Bank

$2.5B

$2.5B

Singapore

Mauritius

Mauritius

USA

OYO Rooms

$2.2B

UK

Cayman Islands

Virgin Islands

USA

Telecom companies are some of the biggest

benefactors of foreign direct investment

Bubbles show which countries Indian companies get their

money from

JIO Platforms

$15B

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

USA

Singapore

UAE

Vodafone IDEA

$10B

Amazon Services

$4.8B

Singapore

Mauritius

Singapore

Luxembourg

One97 Communications

Think and Learn

$2.9B

$2.7B

Singapore

Canada

Hong Kong

Belgium

UK

Saudi Arabia

Cayman Islands

USA

Cayman Islands

Singapore

UK

Qatar

Mauritius

Netherlands

Taiwan

USA

Mauritius

Airtel

Axis Bank

$2.5B

$2.5B

Singapore

Mauritius

Mauritius

USA

OYO Rooms

$2.2B

UK

Cayman Islands

Virgin Islands

USA